Paula Bernstein and Elyse Schein: The Separated Twins Who Lived the Same Life

Paula Bernstein and Elyse Schein: The Separated Twins Who Lived the Same Life
Photo: Art Institute of Chicago

Paula Bernstein and Elyse Schein were identical twins separated at birth who grew up with no idea the other existed. They did not just look the same, they lived lives that mirrored each other in ways that feel impossible to explain.

The two women finally met when they were 35 years old. They found out they had both been editors of their high school newspapers and both went on to study film in college. Even their habits and tastes in books were almost exactly the same. It was like they were two copies of the same person living in different places for three decades. This story is a wild look at how much of our lives might be decided before we are even born.

How did Paula and Elyse find each other?

Elyse Schein lived in Paris in 2003 and decided it was time to find her birth mother. She was 35 and felt a pull to know where she came from. She contacted the adoption agency in New York where she was born. When the social worker called her back, the news was not what she expected. The woman told Elyse that she was a twin. This was a huge shock because Elyse had lived her whole life as an only child. She had no clue there was another version of her out there.

The agency told her that her sister, Paula, lived in Brooklyn. Paula was also an only child and had no idea about Elyse. The agency gave Paula the news, and she was just as stunned. They agreed to meet at a cafe in New York City. Paula walked in and saw a woman who had her face, her hair, and her smile. They talked for hours and realized they were not just sisters. They were like the same person living in two different bodies. They even wore the same kind of clothes and liked the same music.

It is fascinating to read about The Jim Twins: Separated at Birth Who Lived the Same Life because their story is so similar to this one. Both pairs of twins showed that nature has a very strong grip on who we become. Paula and Elyse found out they both loved writing and had both worked as journalists. They both struggled with the same health issues and had similar fears. It makes you wonder if we really have as much choice in our lives as we think we do.

Paula Bernstein and Elyse Schein: The Separated Twins Who Lived the Same Life
Photo from the web

The secret study that changed their lives

As Paula and Elyse spent more time together, they started to ask questions. Why were they separated? Why were they never told about each other? They found out they were part of a secret study run by Dr. Peter Neubauer. He was a famous child psychiatrist who wanted to answer the oldest question in science. Is it nature or nurture that makes us who we are? To find out, he worked with an adoption agency to split up sets of twins and triplets. He sent them to different families and never told the parents that the children had siblings.

This study was kept secret for decades. Dr. Neubauer and his team visited the families for years. They told the parents they were just doing a normal study on child development. They filmed the girls, gave them tests, and watched them grow up. Paula and Elyse were like lab rats in an experiment they never signed up for. The researchers watched them hit the same milestones at the same time, even though they lived miles apart. It is a dark part of history that feels like something out of a movie.

The researchers even picked families that were similar. Both Paula and Elyse were adopted by Jewish families in the New York area. Both sets of parents were well-off and valued education. This was done so the scientists could see if small changes in the home made a big difference. But what they found was that the twins stayed very much the same. This kind of Human-interest story shows the strange side of science and how it can hurt people in the search for truth.

The strange things they had in common

When you look at the details of their lives, it gets even weirder. Both women had a passion for film and writing. Paula was a film critic and Elyse had moved to Paris to study filmmaking. They both had a very specific sense of humor that their friends always noticed. When they met, they finished each other's sentences almost right away. They even had the same hand gestures and walked with the same stride. It was like looking in a mirror that could talk back to you.

They both suffered from bouts of sadness at the same times in their lives. They had the same taste in food and hated the same things. For example, they both loved the same obscure books that most people had never heard of. You can find more stories about twins separated at birth on this site that show these patterns are more common than you think. It is not just a one-time thing. It happens over and over again with separated twins.

One of the most touching things was their shared love for writing. They both felt a need to tell stories. After they met, they decided to write a book together about their experience. They called it Identical Strangers. Writing the book helped them process the anger they felt toward the doctors who split them up. It also helped them bond. They had to learn how to be sisters while also dealing with the fact that they were strangers for 35 years.

Why were they separated at birth?

The reason behind the separation is the hardest part to hear. Dr. Neubauer believed that twins had a bond that was too strong. He thought that if they grew up together, they would never become their own people. He wanted to see if they could develop separate identities if they were apart. The adoption agency went along with it because they thought it would help the children. They did not think about the emotional pain of losing a twin.

Paula and Elyse were born to a mother who struggled with mental health issues. The agency used this as a reason to study them. They wanted to see if the girls would develop the same issues as their mother. This was a very cold way to look at two babies. The study was finally shut down in 1980, but the results were sealed in a vault at Yale University. They are not allowed to be fully opened until the year 2065. This is because many of the people involved are still alive.

When Paula and Elyse tried to get their records, they hit many walls. They wanted to know what the researchers saw when they were kids. They finally got some of the files, but many parts were blacked out. It is hard to imagine having your childhood recorded by strangers and then being told you cannot see the notes. They used their skills as writers to fight for the truth. They wanted the world to know what happened to them so it would never happen to anyone else again.

Living life as a twin after 35 years

Starting a relationship with a twin you never knew is not easy. Paula and Elyse had to figure out how to fit into each other's lives. Paula had a husband and kids. Elyse was living a different life in a different country. They had missed so much. They missed every birthday, every graduation, and every big life moment. They had to grieve for the time they lost while trying to enjoy the time they had found.

They found that they had the same temper and the same way of arguing. This made their early meetings a bit rocky. They were so alike that they would clash over small things. But they also had a deep understanding of each other that no one else could match. They knew what the other was thinking without saying a word. This is a common thing that twins report, but for them, it was brand new and a bit scary.

They also had to deal with the fact that their parents had kept secrets from them. Their adoptive parents did not know they were twins, but they did know they were part of a study. The parents felt guilty once the truth came out. Paula and Elyse had to navigate these family feelings while also building their own bond. They spent a lot of time talking about their childhoods to see where their lives crossed paths without them knowing.

What this tells us about being human

The story of Paula and Elyse makes us think about our own lives. How much of who you are comes from your parents? How much comes from the house you grew up in? If you had been raised by a different family, would you still like the same movies? Would you still have the same job? These twins suggest that a lot of our personality is baked into our DNA from the very start. It is a bit humbling to think we might be following a script written by our genes.

But they also showed that they are individuals. Even though they had so much in common, they had different memories and different friends. Their experiences shaped them in unique ways. Paula lived a more settled life in the suburbs for a while, while Elyse was more of a traveler. These small differences are what make us human. We are a mix of what we are born with and what we choose to do with it. Their story is a powerful reminder of the bond between siblings and the ethics of science.

Today, Paula and Elyse are still in each other's lives. They proved that even after 35 years of being apart, you can still find your way back to your family. Their story is one of the most famous cases in the study of twins. It continues to fascinate people because it touches on the mystery of the human soul. We all want to know what makes us who we are, and Paula and Elyse give us a very clear, if slightly haunting, answer.

If you found out today that you had a secret twin living a life just like yours, what is the first thing you would ask them? It is a question that makes you look at your own habits and wonders where they really came from.

Comments